Header
Name : A cup of tea:
Version: Typical English
Equipment Requirements
Teapot
Process Inputs:
Dried Tea Leaves (optionally in 'Bags')
Water
Energy for Heating
Parameters
2g of leaves per cup
Procedure:
Pre-heat teapot by using a short flush with nearly boiling water.
Put tea in Hot Teapot, then Add boiling water to a teapot.
Stir (optional).
Wait 3* minutes for tea to brew. (*time is a operational/user choice)
Put Milk in Cup - This can be done while the tea is brewing.
Please note - the milk Must be added to the cup Before the Tea!, (This is a Critical Recipe Parameter).
Pour tea into cup.
Slurp it up
Good things found in Vista:
Windows Key the type the name of the application - :
Bingo!
Friday, 13 June 2008
Wednesday, 11 June 2008
Sequences are not Recipes
Dave
I completely disagree with a heck of a lot of what you say part 5 blog.
The latest is
Is that a Sequence or is that a Recipe? The answer is - You say Yes
I say no, in fact I say do not even compare them. To do so undermines the great concept that S88 provides, - separation of Recipes and Equipment.
S88. 01 is not actually about Control, it is about how to describe recipes and the physical equipment they have to run with. The cookbook and the kitchen.
Chop with knife number 42, turn on the power for the cooker, rotate knob 3 to set the temperature on the oven, etc is in the equipment sequence.
Chop the carrots, put in preheated oven is in the recipe.
These are not the same, they interface but are not equivalent.
The formula in a packing machine, just like the temperature of the oven in the recipe and the set point for the mixing tank are local copies of the recipe formula - part of the control recipe and derived from the master recipe.
Your statements on this blog are potentially damaging to the value of S88 Part 1.
Part 1 by the way should be left unchanged, if I had a vote I would vote against the update and for the original.
I completely disagree with a heck of a lot of what you say part 5 blog.
The latest is
Is that a Sequence or is that a Recipe? The answer is - You say Yes
I say no, in fact I say do not even compare them. To do so undermines the great concept that S88 provides, - separation of Recipes and Equipment.
S88. 01 is not actually about Control, it is about how to describe recipes and the physical equipment they have to run with. The cookbook and the kitchen.
Chop with knife number 42, turn on the power for the cooker, rotate knob 3 to set the temperature on the oven, etc is in the equipment sequence.
Chop the carrots, put in preheated oven is in the recipe.
These are not the same, they interface but are not equivalent.
The formula in a packing machine, just like the temperature of the oven in the recipe and the set point for the mixing tank are local copies of the recipe formula - part of the control recipe and derived from the master recipe.
Your statements on this blog are potentially damaging to the value of S88 Part 1.
Part 1 by the way should be left unchanged, if I had a vote I would vote against the update and for the original.
MS Vista
I make and sell software for Control Engineers to design their systems with. Of course it is Microsoft based, sorry you open source people out there, but MS is so much more productive for me.
I have wondered whether, or even when, it will be feasible to convert ControlDraw to a web served application, like those that Google does. Maybe I could stuff it full of adverts and retire on the revenue, but that is not my intention yet.
My customers, at least those who work sometimes from their new gleaming home PC's are buying Vista machines these days, and I found that some of them could not run CD
So, ControlDraw Ltd bought me a new Laptop with Vista, and in a day the problem was fixed.
However, I have just had 3 black screens in succession, after installing Vista SP1 and Visual Studio 2008. It took a Safe Start then another reboot to get the machine running properly again.
I thought Vista was not supposed to to that. I guess Vista is still Beta- but in reality so is all software. And Standards. They have flaws that get fixed over time. (unlike S88, but that is not fair as S88 is not like that, it does not need fixing)
Vista is nice, but another big flaw is that I cannot get VB6 Service packs to install.
That looks to me like MS forcing up their revenues, I cannot find an excuse for it. I should be able to use my existing development setup, that I have paid them for.
Notwithstanding, I am now playing with the latest and greatest development tools from MS
I have wondered whether, or even when, it will be feasible to convert ControlDraw to a web served application, like those that Google does. Maybe I could stuff it full of adverts and retire on the revenue, but that is not my intention yet.
My customers, at least those who work sometimes from their new gleaming home PC's are buying Vista machines these days, and I found that some of them could not run CD
So, ControlDraw Ltd bought me a new Laptop with Vista, and in a day the problem was fixed.
However, I have just had 3 black screens in succession, after installing Vista SP1 and Visual Studio 2008. It took a Safe Start then another reboot to get the machine running properly again.
I thought Vista was not supposed to to that. I guess Vista is still Beta- but in reality so is all software. And Standards. They have flaws that get fixed over time. (unlike S88, but that is not fair as S88 is not like that, it does not need fixing)
Vista is nice, but another big flaw is that I cannot get VB6 Service packs to install.
That looks to me like MS forcing up their revenues, I cannot find an excuse for it. I should be able to use my existing development setup, that I have paid them for.
Notwithstanding, I am now playing with the latest and greatest development tools from MS
Friday, 6 June 2008
Recipe Control
I see that Dave has blogged about Recipe Control
"No where that I can find does the ISA88 standard deal with “Recipe Control” as it does with “Equipment Control.” it says. My jaw dropped when I read this so I posted a fairly mocking response, but as usual it takes days before comments on that 'blog' appears if at all.
I think that the post indicates that the most fundamental purpose and meaning of Part 1 is not understood by the poster. Let me explain why I say that.
The entire Original Part 1 is all about Recipes and how to make stuff according to a Recipe.
And keeping the Recipes independent from the equipment and yet being able to run the recipes in the available equipment. The Equipment gets Controlled Yes. The Recipe provides the Set Points and the Procedural Sequence, but the Equipment Does the Control!
Part 1 quite rightly strictly excludes defining how to program either recipes or the control of equipment. Part 1 as it is does a very valuable job of providing a framework in terms of the words that can be used, and models that can provide a structure where those words can be used to describe the required Recipes and the Equipment Control.
Recipe Control is a meaningless term - unless we are talking about how to manage the Recipes themselves. Such as making sure that they are kept safely, version management, ensuring that a Recipe is up to date and approved for use etc.
When thinking about Recipes, it always helps to use the cooking analogy. So what do the cook books say about Controlling a Recipe. Try Searching for Cooking Control. Did that help?
By the way, Dave's 'blog' is not really a blog, but never mind. If you comment on this one it will appear - immediately, please feel free.
"No where that I can find does the ISA88 standard deal with “Recipe Control” as it does with “Equipment Control.” it says. My jaw dropped when I read this so I posted a fairly mocking response, but as usual it takes days before comments on that 'blog' appears if at all.
I think that the post indicates that the most fundamental purpose and meaning of Part 1 is not understood by the poster. Let me explain why I say that.
The entire Original Part 1 is all about Recipes and how to make stuff according to a Recipe.
And keeping the Recipes independent from the equipment and yet being able to run the recipes in the available equipment. The Equipment gets Controlled Yes. The Recipe provides the Set Points and the Procedural Sequence, but the Equipment Does the Control!
Part 1 quite rightly strictly excludes defining how to program either recipes or the control of equipment. Part 1 as it is does a very valuable job of providing a framework in terms of the words that can be used, and models that can provide a structure where those words can be used to describe the required Recipes and the Equipment Control.
Recipe Control is a meaningless term - unless we are talking about how to manage the Recipes themselves. Such as making sure that they are kept safely, version management, ensuring that a Recipe is up to date and approved for use etc.
When thinking about Recipes, it always helps to use the cooking analogy. So what do the cook books say about Controlling a Recipe. Try Searching for Cooking Control. Did that help?
By the way, Dave's 'blog' is not really a blog, but never mind. If you comment on this one it will appear - immediately, please feel free.
Wednesday, 2 April 2008
The History of Diagrams
After my comments about diagrams and UML I checked out the history of diagrams.
I found a very nice presentation on the topic here, it follows them from the earliest - Maps, Geometrics etc on - thanks Nottingham university and Thannasis.
It happens to be also a very good introduction to UML. Now, my types of diagram such as those for Unit and, Equipment Modules, Operations and Phases etc are not really part of the classic UML set, but it is quite easy to see how they could be part of a Control Modeling Language that conforms with much of the UML rules.
Maybe if I get time I will write it up. Or introduce the idea to S88 Part 5.
I found a very nice presentation on the topic here, it follows them from the earliest - Maps, Geometrics etc on - thanks Nottingham university and Thannasis.
It happens to be also a very good introduction to UML. Now, my types of diagram such as those for Unit and, Equipment Modules, Operations and Phases etc are not really part of the classic UML set, but it is quite easy to see how they could be part of a Control Modeling Language that conforms with much of the UML rules.
Maybe if I get time I will write it up. Or introduce the idea to S88 Part 5.
Wednesday, 26 March 2008
WBF 2008 USA Conference
No, I am not there, but it is good to see Walt Boyes reporting at Sound Off in near real time from the latest WBF conference.
Walt has kindly summarised several papers - those that can be put into words - perhaps not the flashy graphics ones.
Nothing new that I could see there, but it all stands repeating.
One paper about the Zen of Project Management makes plenty of good points, slow down to speed up, improve the equirements analysis and so on. Really not new but totally valid. But here we go again, UML. Sorry but no, we do not need UML for process control, and believe me I have tried, years ago. Control Engineers have had better diagrams than UML provides (for our stuff) for decades. And the software tools too.
Walt has kindly summarised several papers - those that can be put into words - perhaps not the flashy graphics ones.
Nothing new that I could see there, but it all stands repeating.
One paper about the Zen of Project Management makes plenty of good points, slow down to speed up, improve the equirements analysis and so on. Really not new but totally valid. But here we go again, UML. Sorry but no, we do not need UML for process control, and believe me I have tried, years ago. Control Engineers have had better diagrams than UML provides (for our stuff) for decades. And the software tools too.
Wednesday, 19 March 2008
Lynn Craig Webcast
This should be worth hearing, Lynn usually is:
WBF Web Sem: Using ISA88 - Approaches, Opinions & Caution
There is unfortunately a charge of $95. Which will greatly reduce the audience, a great shame. It should be free and on YouTube. And Part 1 should be a free download.
WBF Web Sem: Using ISA88 - Approaches, Opinions & Caution
There is unfortunately a charge of $95. Which will greatly reduce the audience, a great shame. It should be free and on YouTube. And Part 1 should be a free download.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)